68 Comments
⭠ Return to thread

Well, here’s thing, as I see it.

The more the SCOTUS majority deflect their duties to the states, the less they have to feel accountable for the obvious mismanagement of the law that has been apparent since Roberts took the big chair. Thomas and Alito aren’t the only ones who need to be gone. He makes the appellation Roberts Court a misnomer, every time he lets the conservative majority walk over him on their way to a “decision”.

Expand full comment

Horrifyingly, it appears that no one is walking over roberts. In fact, HE is leading the parade to a full fascist dictatorship. He crafted the presidential immunity law and TOLD the other five to sign it. For real. I was beyond stunned to learn this recently.

Expand full comment

Well, that’s disappointing.

“Thomas, the longest-serving justice on the bench and arguably the most conservative of the nine, has become more influential over the years, to the point that some commentators have declared him more powerful than Roberts.

Not this year, so very unlike 2022, when Thomas and other conservatives pushed through the Dobbs ruling and Roberts stood alone between embittered factions. The chief justice chided his colleagues on both sides for displaying “a relentless freedom from doubt on the legal issue.”

This year, he stepped to the right, and he displayed no doubt.”

Expand full comment

I rep when Thomas was appointed. There was lots of talk about him being not very bright.

Expand full comment

We were wrong.

Expand full comment

("We" who?)

Expand full comment

Those of us who engaged in the "lots of talk."

Expand full comment

Evil, brilliant, and I think, lazy.

Expand full comment

He creeped me out 32 years ago. When he manipulated the white Democratic males in Congress by saying, "This is a high tech LYNCHING!!!" -- they all put their tails between their legs (and yes, Joe, you were the head of this Committee) and immediately voted the stinker in. By then, who gave a damn what Anita Hill had to say? And why listen to her witnesses, or to the other women whom he had sexually harassed and/or assaulted?

Expand full comment

Indeed. Anita Hill was an uppity black woman. Why would all those white guys give her any respect. The things she said about Thomas were shocking to me.

Expand full comment

It was awful. I was shocked, too. He was (and surely is still) DISGUSTING. Sheer misogyny, and racism before they only approved clearance so no one would think that THEY were "racists".

Expand full comment

Does somebody have a different view

Expand full comment

No kidding.

Expand full comment

"In past decades, when the justices took up major tests of presidential power, they achieved unanimity." Roberts didn't even both with trying.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Oct 8
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Impeachment is a waste of time and money without 66 votes in the Senate. I wish I was wrong.

Expand full comment

Vote Blue.

Expand full comment

He's a really smooth jerk.

Expand full comment

that's what I used to think, and I'm sure it's what we're SUPPOSED to think. but this recent leaked stuff about the remarkably active role Roberts took in leading his putz compatriots to issue the worst of their recent decisions buries that comfortable little myth very deep indeed.

Expand full comment

Which justices demured? Voted to uphold lower court?

Expand full comment

We need to guess??

Expand full comment

Tom, thanks for saving me some keystrokes. Thank you also for, as always, fighting the good fight.

Life is a little hectic right now, recovering from Helene. Trees are down everywhere. I didn’t have major damage to my house, but if my neighbor hadn’t cut down 6 big pine trees last year, I might not be here. This is worse than the ice storm 10 years ago, when Jim Cantore himself came to Augusta. I’ve been over a week without running water (I have children close by, thank God, who still have theirs). I’ll get by.

Expand full comment

Whoa! Talk about luck wrapping itself around you. Stay safe!

Expand full comment

You know, when she cutdown all those trees, I used to say to myself, jokingly, “You’re not from around here, are you?” Both of our houses face south, in Georgia. I treasure my shade, and grieve the loss. She cut down her afternoon shade. Now, all I feel is unending gratitude.

Expand full comment

Though , I have to say, the two she spared are now in my yard, hence, a little snark, along with contrition and gratitude.

Expand full comment

Stay safe and good luck.

Expand full comment

Thank you, Hannah.

Expand full comment

All the Best to you, Camilla.

Expand full comment

Thank you, MaryPat. I got my internet back on today. I feel normal again. Cheap romance novels only take you so far. 😉

Expand full comment