Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gloria Horton-Young's avatar

TCinLA—Thomas Cleaver to those who haven't spent enough time in the political trenches to earn nickname privileges—has this way of writing that makes you forget to breathe. Not in the romantic comedy way, but in the "someone finally said what we've all been thinking and dear god it's even worse when you see it in print" way. This article lays it down in no uncertain words.

Steven Beschloss asked very pointed questions today unlike he ever has before. It's funny how sometimes the most mild-mannered people snap into focus with laser-sharp clarity.

American politics in 2025? Just when you think you've seen it all—when you've witnessed every possible permutation of bad judgment, poor timing, and catastrophic decision-making—someone like Vance comes along and proves that rock bottom has a basement.

Let's talk about this, shall we?

1. Do real Americans support neo-Nazism?

Listen, my mother used to say that some questions answer themselves. This is one of them. Real Americans—the kind who put their lives on the line at Normandy, who liberated concentration camps, who came home with nightmares and medals and a bone-deep understanding of evil—they didn't fight Nazism so their grandchildren could play footsie with it at diplomatic functions. Vance might want to spend an afternoon at the World War II Memorial. Maybe bring a notebook.

2. How ugly were Vance's comments?

They were the kind of ugly that makes you want to take a shower, except no amount of hot water and expensive soap can wash away the feeling that somewhere, every history professor in America is reaching for their blood pressure medication. Fact-checkers are throwing their hands up in despair, probably contemplating career changes. Maybe they'll all become pastry chefs. At least flour and sugar don't try to rewrite history.

3. How wrong was he to interject himself into Germany's election?

Remember that time in college when you thought it would be fun to light sparklers indoors? This is worse. This is like walking into your neighbor's house during a family argument, dousing everything in kerosene, and calling it "constructive intervention." The diplomatic equivalent of bringing match to a gas leak and then acting surprised when everyone runs screaming.

4. How do you view his 30-minute meeting with the leader of the neo-Nazi AfD party?

It's like watching the worst possible dating show on earth. Plot: Authoritarianism and Opportunism walk into a bar. They have a 30-minute speed date that threatens to set democracy on fire. The maître d' is Democracy itself, watching in horror as they order totalitarianism for two. It would be funny if it weren't terrifying. It would be absurd if it weren't real.

5. What do you expect will be the fallout now and in the coming years?

Remember when Harry met Sally, they fell in love? Well, when Vance met the AfD, Europe fell out of love—with us. With our promises. With the idea that America could be trusted to remember its own history. It's the kind of breakup that leaves everyone changing their phone numbers and blocking each other on social media, except this isn't about who gets to keep the friends in the divorce. This is about the future of democratic alliances. And right now, Europe is probably downloading a dating app called "Alternative Allies."

.

In the end, it's not just about Vance. It's about who we were, who we wanted to be, and we have voted to let diplomatic amateurs turn international relations into a reality show where the prize is the destruction of 75 years of trans-Atlantic trust.

Expand full comment
Bruce Culver's avatar

“All the good will we’ve built up since 1918, pissed away in three weeks by a fucking draft-dodging coward.”

FUCKIN" A! .....

Expand full comment
51 more comments...

No posts